Chart 7: Miscellaneous Developmental Lines
Chart 7: Miscellaneous Developmental Lines
A shorter chart correlating several less-central developmental models against the basic-structures spine, plus a second table (a different row spine — see Chart 1 for why these don't force-merge) correlating modal-experience, empathy, and gender/affect models.
Transcribed and cross-checked against the source page images
(library/2000-integral-psychology-images/00046.jpg-00047.jpg); draft, not yet
independently verified by a second pass. Some cells in the source are sparse or
ambiguously positioned at this image resolution — marked "—" rather than guessed.
Structures, erotic relationships, needs, and exchange
| Level | Structure | Erotic relationships (Fortune) | Needs (Maslow) | Levels of "food" (relational exchange, Wilber) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sensorimotor | Matter | — | Physical | Material exchange |
| Sensation | Instinctual | Physiological | Food, labor | |
| Perception | — | — | — | |
| Exocept | — | — | — | |
| Phantasmic-emotional | Impulse/emotion | Emotional | Beginning of safety | Emotional exchange |
| Image | — | — | Sex, safety, power | |
| Symbol | — | Safety | — | |
| Rep-mind | Endocept | — | — | — |
| Concept | Concrete mental | — | Belongingness, care | |
| Conop | Rule/role, early | — | Belongingness | Mental exchange |
| Rule/role, late | — | — | Membership, discourse | |
| Formop | Formal, early | Abstract mental | Self-esteem | Self-reflective exchange |
| Formal, late | — | — | — | |
| Postformal | Vision-logic, early | — | Self-actualization | Autonomous exchange |
| Vision-logic, middle | — | — | — | |
| Vision-logic, late | — | — | — | |
| Psychic | Early (vision) | Concrete spirit | Self-transcendence | Soul exchange, psychic vision, God communion |
| Late | — | — | — | |
| Subtle | Early (archetype) | — | — | God union |
| Late | — | — | — | |
| Causal | Early (formless) | Pure spirit | — | Spiritual exchange, Godhead identity |
| Late | — | — | — | |
| Nondual | Early | — | — | Sahaja |
| Middle | — | — | — | |
| Late | — | — | — |
Modal experience, empathy, gender identity, and affect
A different, seven-level spine (Chinen's "modal experience" model), correlated with Benack's empathy stages and Wilber's own gender-identity and affect columns (the gender-identity and affect columns partly overlap with Chart 1's gender/worldview table).
| Modal experience (Chinen) | Empathy (Benack) | Gender identity (Wilber) | Affect (Wilber) |
|---|---|---|---|
| — | — | Morphological-genetic givens | Reactivity, sensations |
| — | — | Undifferentiated | Physiostates: touch, temperature, pleasure, pain |
| — | — | Differentiated basic-gender identity | Protoemotions: tension, fear, rage, satisfaction |
| 1. Enactment | Unwilling to assume others' perspective | Gender conventionality (norms) | 2° emotions: anxiety, anger, wishing, liking, safety |
| 2. Reflection | Unable to assume others' perspective | Gender consistency | 3° emotions: love, joy, depression, hate, belongingness |
| 3. Representation, pragmatic | Willing to assume others' perspective | — | 4° emotions: universal affect, global justice, care, compassion, all-human love, worldcentric altruism |
| 5. Hermeneutic | Able to assume others' perspective | Gender androgyny (trans-differentiated) | — |
| 6. Attunement | — | — | Awe, rapture, all-species love, compassion |
| 7. Enlightenment | — | Archetypal gender union (tantra) | Ananda, ecstasy, love-bliss, saintly commitment |
| — | — | Beyond gender | Infinite freedom-release, bodhisattvic compassion; one taste |
Note: the source numbers this sequence 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7 — stage 4 is not printed on the source page (not a transcription omission).
See Also
- Chart 1: Wilber Correlations — the fuller version of the basic-structures/affect/gender-identity columns this chart partly repeats
- Waves and Streams — the levels/lines distinction these miscellaneous lines are all instances of
